Laughs On Ice: Ct Man Scores With 'Heated Rivalry' Musical Parody Hit

All photos by Matthew Murray

A year ago Dylan MarcAurele’s friends kept urging him to watch what was quickly becoming a cultural phenom: the new HBO series “Heated Rivalry,” about two opposing — and very libidinous — hockey superstars who secretly hook up, only to discover that feelings were deeper than either realized.

More addicted to reality TV than scripted shows, MarcAurele — who grew up in East Granby — finally checked out what everyone was talking about.

Before the six-episode series concluded in December, 2025, MarcAurele not only joined the fandom but also began envisioning an affectionate musical parody of the show. Within three weeks he wrote the book, musics, lyrics and orchestrations for “Heated Rivalry: The Unauthorized Parody Musical.”

“I only have an interest in parodying things that I love,” he said from his Upper East Side home, “and this series was so brilliantly written, filmed, produced, edited — everything.”

His goal was a one-off pop concert but when that immediately sold out, producer-friend Alan Kliffer saw it as a fully staged production. An off-Broadway show, directed by Kliffer, was arranged in a matter of weeks and opened in May at The Culture Club in Chelsea .

Jay Armstrong Johnson and Jimin Moon — both actors with many Broadway credits — were cast in the seven-actor show, which opened to critical praise. The New Yorker called it “a flat-out terrific musical, no caveats necessary.” Time Out gave the show 4 out of 5 stars noting “this scrappy show is an unexpected delight.”

Its run has been extended several times and is now playing into January. An album of the music has also been made. “It’s been nuts,” said MarcAurele, 31.

Like the Rachel Reid’s best-selling steamy book and Jacob Tierney’s fleshy television adaptation, MarcAurele’s version centers on Canadian Dry player Shane Hollander and Ilya Rozanov, his Russian rival, who begin a clandestine affair, navigating its complex sexual and emotional dynamics. (And no, the only nudity the show is a flash of butt at the show’s end.)

MarcAurele said he understands those who can’t imagine hockey lovers singing, “but when we sing we’re expressing our inner-most thoughts and insecurities so now we can see what they’re thinking — though when it’s a parody musical the writer is taking some liberties.” One highlight is when Ilya sings: “This Fuck Isn’t Like the Last Fuck.”

But his approach, MarcAurele said, isn’t simply about jokes but a show with strong characters, memorable songs, and genuine emotional stakes.

Though he was fairly sure his parody fell within copyright laws, he was never-the-less anxious when HBO came to an early reading. “I was holding my breath the entire time but they said they loved it and couldn’t wait to see it off-Broadway. Rachel Reid said she considers it to be a badge of honor.”

Reid and everyone associated with the series, including leads Connor Storrie and Hudson Williams, have been invited, “but they’ve been pretty busy with the second season and the new book,” said MarcAurele.

Following high school graduation in East Granby, MarcAurele, went to Harvard where he soon switched majors from economics to music, and composing works for student productions, honing his skills as an orchestrator and songwriter.

Writing blind to Broadway music director Alex Lacamoire, MarcAurele said he would take any unpaid position. Lacamoire said yes and the fledgling composer arrived in New York as a music assistant on “Hamilton.” (He soon was upgraded to a salary.)

MarcAurele’s early work circled around the comic genre with the musical parodies “The Real Housewives of NYC: The Unauthorized Parody Musical” and “MEG4N,” an unauthorized parody musical based on the horror film “M3GAN.”

MarcAurele’s work earned him a position with the BMI Lehman Engel Musical Theatre Workshop, a Jonathan Larson Grant, fellowships from the Dramatists Guild Foundation and the Richard Rodgers Award for MarcAurele’ music for the show “Lewis Loves Clark” (with book and lyrics by Mike Ross.) That show is being further developed with director Robert O’Hara.

“Pop Off, Michelangelo!” which had runs in London and Edinburgh Fringe last year is a comic musical imagining of Michelangelo and Leonardo da Vinci as competitive, closeted Renaissance artists. (“It’s really about me working out feelings of growing up Catholic and queer.”) MarcAurele is also working on “The Passion of the Laberdoodle,” a true story about the man — to his life’s regret — began the designer dog phenomenon.

MarcAurele’s shows echoes the current popularity of loopy downtown musicals, such as “Silence! The Musical,” “Titanique,” and “Oh, Mary!” (the latter two which eventually landed on Broadway).

But MarcAurele isnt alone in seeing comic gold on ice. There are four major live stage parodies of the series so far — not counting countless TikTok and YouTube spoofs, fan-produced videos, and drag performances. All four stage shows — including MarcAurele’s version — played the Edinburg Fringe in Scotland in August.

MarcAurele said it’s been a game changer year. “I wasn’t sure whether I could make a living as a writer and I now feel so much more confident, with less of that ‘imposter syndrome.’ It’s the coolest feeling.”

Would there be second musical parody when the next season of the series comes out in late spring? “OMG,” said MarcAurele. “I might have to be institutionalized.”

Update on ‘Heated ‘Rivalry’

The HBO television series is based on Rachel Reid’s “Game Changer” books about the world of Canadian hockey and its gay and bi players.

“Heated Rivalry” was the second in the series of books and was the basis of the first season of the streaming series.

The second season of the television series — which began filming during the summer and is expected to continue through December — is based on the series’ fifth book, “The Long Game,” which follows the Ilya-Shane romance. Just as the first season included the storyline in the book series’ first novel, the second television season will also includes elements of the fifth book on the series, “Role Model.” The second season is expected to drop on HBO in May or June, according to the series’ creator, Jacob Tierney.

“Unrivaled,” the third book centered on Ilya and Shane — and the sixth and final book of the series —will be out this summer and concludes the “Heated Rivalry” trilogy. There is no announcement beyond the HBO series’ second season.